|
|
CLEW Weekly
Friday, 19 Jan 2024
|
This week’s round-up of the top energy transition news and analysis from Germany and beyond, as well as the latest from the CLEW Journalism Network. Sign up to our Briefing for daily news, get CLEW background resources including factsheets and dossiers, or join the community of international energy transition journalists at www.cleanenergywire.org.
|
|
|
|
European Union
by Kira Taylor, Brussels
As 2024 begins, all eyes are on the European Commission’s 2040 climate target proposal. It is due to be published in February and comes amid an increasingly fractious environment for green politics and ahead of EU parliamentary elections in June. The target is a stepping stone between the European Union’s 2030 target and its 2050 net zero goal, as the 27 countries aim to be the world’s first climate
neutral continent. In December, the EU worked hard to live up to that goal at home and abroad. In Brussels, provisional agreements were made on a range of legislation to help Europe transition to a sustainable economy, including laws to reform the electricity market and to green transport and buildings. Meanwhile, on the global stage, the EU machine came in swinging at COP28, driving a hard line on fossil fuels at a summit that ultimately became the
first to address these in the final conclusions.
Stories to watch in the weeks ahead - 2040 climate target. The European Commission will publish a plan for its 2040 climate target
on 6 February. The EU already has a target to reduce net emissions by 55 percent by 2030 and a goal to reach net zero emissions by 2050, so the 2040 target will act as a step between these. The EU’s scientific advisory board has
set the bar high, saying the target should be a net reduction of 90-95 percent, based on 1990 levels. However, it has also
warned that, without further action, the EU will fall short of its climate goals, including the mid-century climate neutrality goal. During hearings with the European Parliament, both EU Green Deal chief Maroš Šefčovič and EU climate chief Wopke Hoekstra said they would “defend” a reduction of at least 90 percent. Support for this target has also come from Denmark,
Bulgaria and Poland. The proposal is likely to be a last big splash ahead of the European elections and could help steer the work of the next Commission.
- Carbon Capture. The same day as it plans to present its proposal for a 2040 target, the European Commission will also publish a “communication on industrial carbon management” – effectively a non-binding action plan. The EU needs to ramp up its efforts to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere or capture it when using fossil fuels, alongside emissions reductions, to meet its goal of countering all emissions by 2050 with an equivalent removal.
According to Bloomberg, the leaked draft states the EU will need to capture as much as 450 million tons of CO2 each year by 2050 - roughly equivalent to today’s
direct CO2 emissions from buildings in the EU. The draft suggests the EU’s power sector would capture more than 100 million tons, while a further 100-200 million tons would need to be captured directly from the atmosphere.
- Final policy push. As European elections loom, the clock is ticking to finalise several puzzle pieces of the European Green Deal. Belgium, which took over the
EU Council presidency on 1 January, is in a race to conclude negotiations on boosting Europe’s clean tech manufacturing with the Net Zero Industry Act, as well as
certification for carbon removals and rules to help slash packaging waste. Negotiations between the European Commission, EU countries and the European Parliament, known as trilogues, on the Net Zero Industry Act will take place on 22 January, while discussions on packaging are planned for 5 February. Meanwhile, some provisional agreements still need to be officially signed off, including the Nature Restoration Law and the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive. Normally, this is a box ticking exercise, but it can occasionally lead to further disputes.
- Political climate heats up. The European Union is preparing for the upcoming elections, taking place on 6-9 June, and Brussels is shifting into campaign mode. It comes as green topics are becoming increasingly controversial in parts of Europe. EU countries, like Germany, have seen increasing
unrest around green policies and the weakening of some policies
aimed at the agricultural sector. This follows protests in Belgium and
the Netherlands over efforts to reduce nitrogen emissions. Some EU legislation, like the Nature Restoration Law, has already been caught in the crossfire. However, most of the EU legislation planned for this mandate has been agreed, leaving little space for change before the elections. How the backlash against green policies affects the implementation of this legislation is still to be seen. Similarly, it may affect the European elections. In turn, this will dictate who gets the next voting majority and top jobs in the European Union, potentially impacting green policies in the next mandate.
The latest from EU policymaking – last month in recap - COP28. The major development in December was the
COP28 climate summit, which became the first to mention the transition away from fossil fuels in the final conclusions. The European Union, represented by EU climate chief Wopke Hoekstra and Spanish Minister for the Ecological Transition Teresa Ribera, pushed hard for ambition and
refused to accept an initial, weaker text. The final COP conclusions include goals the EU championed, including tripling renewable energy capacity, doubling energy efficiency and, all-importantly, transitioning from fossil fuels. Hoekstra called the final text the
“beginning of the end of fossil fuels”.
- New legislation agreed. Back home in Brussels, December saw a raft of new legislation provisionally agreed as part of the European Green Deal laws. This includes a
reform of the electricity market, aiming to boost renewables and stabilise prices. Meanwhile, leaky buildings were addressed in the EU’s Energy Performance of Buildings Directive and emissions from industrial installations, including intensive livestock farms, were tackled under the Industrial Emissions Directive. Policymakers also agreed to
establish common internal market rules for renewable and natural gases and hydrogen. Big pushes have also been made in the world of transport, with
a deal on emissions limits for road vehicles (Euro 7),
a deal to boost cross-border transport infrastructure, and a deal in January on new measures to cut emissions from heavy-duty vehicles agreed. All of these still need to be rubberstamped before they become law.
- Emergency measures extended. In December, EU energy ministers
extended the runtime of emergency measures adopted to tackle soaring energy prices and move the European economy away from Russian fossil fuels. These include accelerated permitting for renewables, a gas price cap and joint gas purchasing. However, prices have never been high enough to trigger the price cap and head of German energy industry association BDEW Kerstin Andreae
warned intervening in the market could have “negative consequences”. The decision to extend the measures follows an agreement to prolong the gas demand reduction target earlier in 2023.
Kira’s picks - Highlights from upcoming events and top reads
Be sure to check out the following articles and podcasts for more details on the most important stories of the day:
[For a bird's-eye view of the EU's climate-friendly transition, check out the
CLEW Guide – How the European Union is trying to legislate a path to net-zero]
|
|
|
Our CLEW Network is growing! We have recently been joined by Aline Flor, a climate journalist covering activism, climate justice, EU policy and adaptation for Público, a Portuguese daily national newspaper; Jordan Gass-Poore', a freelance journalist who hosts the podcast series "Hazard NJ" which highlights the intersection of pollution and climate change in the Garden State; Deep Vakil from India who covers commodities and energy for
Reuters with a specific focus on the evolving power grid, energy transition, and extreme weather; Olaf Geurts, a freelance journalist from the Netherlands focusing on citizens' energy, nuclear, oil and gas producers and cybersecurity of renewable infrastructure; Erin Rizzato Devlin, a freelance journalist in the UK journalist covering environmental ethics, policy making and just transition; Neel Kamal, who covers sustainable agriculture, environment and climate change for The Times of India; Paul Krantz, a freelance journalist based in Berlin who covers e-mobility, lithium supply chains and mining; Aniket Narawad, a freelance data journalist based in Berlin; Josh Axelrod, a freelancer in Berlin who focuses on the link between disinformation and climate change; Robert Kibet, a freelance climate journalist from Kenya whose work has been published by Inter Press Service, Deutsche Welle, Reuters and The Guardian; Nuria Tesón a freelance journalist based in Spain where she covers agriculture, climate and conflict and Roberto Sposini, chief mobility editor at LifeGate.it.
Find out more about our global network of climate and energy reporters via the
CLEW Network map.
16 Jan 2024
CLEW grant winners Gabriela Ramírez and Patrick Egwu dug deep into the politics behind deep-sea mining. The International Seabed Authority (ISA), a UN body, governs half of the Earth's surface and has allocated exploration contracts to several countries and private companies. Who will benefit from the mining, what does it mean for pristine environmental areas in the oceans and how will the extracted metals further the energy transition? In this blog post, Gabriela and Patrick share their
lessons learned on covering this issue across borders.
03 Mar - 06 Mar 2024
[Applications are closed]
Populist leaders and parties are on the rise in many European countries. In the Netherlands, the far right politician Geert Wilders could become the next prime minister, with the BBB (Farmer-Citizen Movement) as a potential coalition partner, which got strong support from farmers who felt threatened by measures of the previous government and the EU. Following the Paris agreement and other activities to fight global warming, agriculture is
gaining more attention from policymakers worldwide. Yet, while steps to reduce emissions in other sectors are also often difficult to implement, changes to farming and food production are particularly emotionally charged as recent protests in Germany proved. To complicate matters, much of the support for agriculture is set through the EU's Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) and accusing "Brussels" of hurting farmers' interests is a common trope in many member states.
While the coalition talks led by Wilders continue, politicians all over Europe try to find answers to populist challenges ahead of the EU elections in June. What follows from the fact that climate action is not a priority issue for most Dutch voters? What are the consequences of the EU’s Nature Restoration Law? How does the EU react to the surge of fake news, which is expected to further increase during the election campaigns? Clean Energy Wire offers journalists based in Europe a chance to find answers to these and other questions during a study trip to the Netherlands and Brussels on 3-6 March 2024.
 |
|
Old and new windmills in the Netherlands. Credit: Tim van der Kuip unsplash |
|
|
|
|
04 Apr 2024
Voters in the EU will head to the polls on 6-9 June 2024 to elect the next European Parliament and help shape the union’s climate policy for the next five years. The months building up to the vote provide many opportunities for journalists to cover European energy and climate issues, and the election itself kicks off the long process of picking the union’s new leadership that will decide climate policy until the end of the decade. This factsheet explains the role of energy and climate
in the EU election year, highlights key moments journalists should have an eye on, and provides expert contacts and resources. [UPDATE adds number of people eligible to vote]
 |
|
Source: E3G. |
|
|
Further background on CLEW
|
|
|
|
|
|
14 Feb 2025
The European Union announced itself as a potential early climate champion in 2018 by pledging to reach climate-neutrality by 2050. Yet, rules and regulations are needed to bring emissions down sufficiently to make ‘climate neutrality’ a feasible reality. A lot of work has been done but much is still on the agenda. Politics clashes with policy, continuing to influence what degree of legislative ambition can be pursued. [UPDATES to Feb '25]
 |
|
Source: European Union. |
|
|
Further background on CLEW
|
|
|
|
|
|
06 Mar 2025
Journalists! Mark your calendars – or rather let us do it for you.
Europe is complicated and even journalists from EU member states sometimes struggle to understand how climate and energy policy is made, and when institutions take key decisions. This timeline flags key European energy and climate reporting events and developments and includes concise background information necessary to jump-start your coverage.
 |
|
Source: European Union. |
|
19 Jan 2024
Tagesspiegel / Focus Online / T-Online
Following weeks of disruptive street blockades, German farmers have threatened to ramp up protests against the planned cuts to agricultural diesel subsidies. The president of the German Farmers' Association (DBV), Joachim Rukwied, called the protests to date "foreshocks,"
reports newspaper
Tagesspiegel. "If nothing changes now, there may be an eruption," Rukwied warned, adding protests would be "more far-reaching" than before and take place all over Germany. Rukwied is set to meet chancellor Olaf Scholz next week Monday (22 January), when the German leader visits the food and agriculture trade fair
Grüne Woche in Berlin. T-Online
reported that farmers protested at the venue already today. Trucking companies said they are also planning protests against government policies. “We will definitely do something,” said the head of logistics association BGL, Dirk Engelhardt, according to a Focus Online
report. The trucking industry says it is being squeezed by higher road tolls and an increase in Germany’s national CO2 price for transport and buildings, while the government planned to cut subsidies for electric trucks.
Protesting farmers have caused major traffic disruption across Germany over the last couple of weeks in
reaction to subsidy cuts by the government which will force agricultural companies to pay more for diesel fuel. Thousands of farming company employees blocked roads and motorways with tractors and other agricultural equipment, demanding that the subsidies are fully reinstated. The cuts were caused by a last-minute budget reshuffling
after a court ruling reduced funds for climate and transformation projects by 60 billion euros. Following the protests, the government agreed to roll back some of the enforced measures and delay others. Agricultural vehicle tax breaks will not be slashed, while diesel tax breaks for farmers will be abolished only gradually, starting this year. But the farmers say the concessions don’t go far enough.
|
Further background on CLEW
|
|
|
|
|
|
18 Jan 2024
Clean Energy Wire
Prolonged drought and more frequent heavy rainfall as a result of climate change will have a significant impact on groundwater levels in central Germany, found a
report by the Lower Saxony State Office for Water Management, Coastal and
Nature Conservation (NLWKN). The findings indicate that extended dry periods and extreme precipitation will result in longer periods of low groundwater levels in summer and autumn, and higher levels in winter and spring. "Human influences on groundwater levels, such as an increased demand for water withdrawals for drinking water supply or agricultural field irrigation, can further amplify these changes," said Uwe Petry, coordinator of the project. However, these effects have not yet been taken into account in the existing models, he warned.
Over the last two decades, groundwater levels in the region have already been on a clear downward trend, with a spell of particularly dry years since 2018 resulting in the sharpest drops in many areas since records began. Regional environment minister, Christian Meyer, said climate change had turned water into a valuable resource that required careful handling. “In order to counter the effects of climate change, we need sustainable water management that is coordinated between all stakeholders.”
With summer temperatures increasing and groundwater levels decreasing,
Lower Saxony and other federal states already took action last year by restricting water use. Germany’s
national water strategy and
natural climate protection action programme are also designed to advance the country’s adaptation efforts.
|
Further background on CLEW
|
|
|
|
|
|
17 Jan 2024
Clean Energy Wire
Germany’s boom in stationary batteries linked to solar PV systems accelerated last year, doubling the total number of units to more than one million,
reports solar industry association BSW. The batteries have a combined capacity of 12 gigawatt-hours - enough to power 1.5 million 2-person households for a day. “The expansion of solar electricity storage
systems has picked up speed rapidly. Both the total number of solar batteries installed and their storage capacity have doubled in just one year,” said the lobby group. "When installing new solar power systems on private buildings, electricity storage systems are now standard. More and more companies are also storing solar power from their roofs to use it around the clock," said the association’s director, Carsten Körnig. He added that the market for home and commercial storage systems grew by over 150 per cent in 2023.
The industry group lamented that current policies still underestimate the potential of battery storage systems, and that market barriers continue to slow their spread. Against this backdrop, BSW welcomed the economy and climate ministry’s proposals for a storage strategy published in December, but said the draft didn’t address central strategic questions regarding the role of batteries in tomorrow’s electricity system. Storage systems should be considered a central pillar of the electricity system, on par with generation, grid, and consumption, the industry association said.
Storage will become key in the next phase of the energy transition, as Germany aims to cover
80 percent of power demand with renewable sources by 2030. A traditional electricity system doesn’t require much storage because power generation can be adjusted to match demand. This changes dramatically as the system uses more renewable energy, as power generation from wind turbines and solar PV systems depends on the weather. This means that production often dramatically exceeds demand but also that current power production can fall well short of what is needed at a given moment.
|
Further background on CLEW
|
|
|
|
|
|
16 Jan 2024
Zeit Online
The German government
has said that the allocation of so-called 'climate bonus' (Klimageld) to citizens to help alleviate high CO2 costs must start at the latest when the new EU emissions trading system for transport and buildings (ETS II) becomes operational in 2027 and is expected to bring higher carbon prices,
Zeit Online reports. This could leave the matter to the country’s next government after the elections scheduled for 2025. "We definitely want and need to get the climate bonus off the ground when European emissions trading enters its second stage from 2027," a government spokeman said.
The government in its coalition treaty agreed to "develop a compensation mechanism" called Klimageld to compensate for rising carbon prices. The two main issues are setting up a mechanism to distribute the money, and making sure that the CO2 price revenues are actually available and not used for other climate measures. Developing a mechanism turned out to be more complicated than originally assumed, the finance ministry said, as there is no existing programme or database which has bank account information for all citizens. This information must be drawn from different sources, said the ministry. In addition, the current budget crisis triggered by a recent constitutional court ruling that upended Germany’s climate policy means that funds are even harder to come by. That is the key reason why the government increased the national CO2 price for transport and heating fuels from 30 to 45 euros per tonne at the start of the year. This hike in CO2 costs
reinforced the discussion about compensating low-income citizens for rising costs due to measures implemented to protect the climate.
Government spokespeople also pointed out that there had already been significant compensation for the sharp rise in energy prices, such as the cancelation of the Renewable Energy Act (EEG) surcharge on electricity as well as gas and electricity price caps. Social Democratic Party (SPD) general secretary Kevin Kühnert called for an alternative social compensation for higher CO₂ prices, such as tax discounts, a long-distance commuter allowance or other measures. The government’s explanation follows
statements made over the weekend by finance minister Christian Lindner, head of the pro-business Free Democrats (FDP),
who said the per capita climate bonus would not be technically feasible before 2025, and the next government would decide about actual payments.
|
Further background on CLEW
|
|
|
|
|
|
16 Jan 2024
Clean Energy Wire
Onshore wind power was significantly expanded in Germany last year, when 745 new turbines with a capacity of more than 3.5 gigawatts (GW) were built across the country. “The buildout is gaining signification traction now,” the German Wind Energy Federation (BWE) said at the release of its
2023 expansion report. Almost 50 percent more turbines were installed than during the previous year, bringing the country’s total onshore wind power capacity to 61 GW. With about 7.5 GW in newly licensed capacity, the expansion appears to be on a solid footing for the foreseeable future. However, while auctioned volumes almost doubled in 2023 compared to the previous year, they still
fell short of the earmarked auction volume of nearly 13 GW, the BWE said in a joint statement with engineering federation VDMA. About 4 GW could be expected in new turbine capacity in 2024, the groups said, adding that “only if policymakers stick to their reforms can the political goals be reached.” A lot still had to be done in securing construction areas, speeding up licensing procedures and facilitating the transport of turbine components. “There needs to be a legal framework that remains in place long term, also beyond the current legislative period” and in coordination between the federal government and the states, BWE head Bärbel Heidebroek said. “Only then can the wind industry
unlock its full potential for becoming a sector that drives the economy forward,” she argued.
The associations urged the government to intensify its
efforts to strengthen renewable energy industries across Europe to prepare the region for an “unequal competition” on global markets. Companies in Germany and Europe are facing largely state-supported companies from China and generously subsidised ones from the U.S. through the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), VDMA head Dennis Rendschmidt said. “There has to be a level playing field to succeed in this environment. A basic requirement for this is a European framework that consolidates demand, creates fair competition within Europe (…) and strengthens the scale-up of production,” Rendschmidt argued. The Global Wind Energy Council (GWEC) expects a worldwide addition of 105 GW onshore turbine capacity this year and 465 GW of new capacity until 2027, with more than half (241 GW) added in China, followed by Europe (87 GW) and the U.S. (50 GW).
|
Further background on CLEW
|
|
|
|
|
|
19 - 28 January: Grüne Woche, food and agriculture trade fair, with chancellor Scholz (22 Jan), BERLIN.
23 January: World Resources Institute's
Stories to Watch 2024, ONLINE.
23 January:
Financing strategy for Germany's natural gas independence, press conference, BERLIN.
23 - 25 January:
Handelsblatt Energiegipfel, with econ min Habeck, BERLIN.
24 January: International Energy Agency (IEA), "Electricity Market Report 2024", ONLINE.
24 January:
EU climate and energy policy in the decisive decade, event and report by
Agora Energiewende, BRUSSELS/ONLINE.
6 February:
European Commission to present communications on 2040 climate target and industrial carbon management, BRUSSELS.
Find more events in the
CLEW calendar.
More online events on climate change/energy/journalism: Clean Energy Wire is maintaining a list of online events and webinars related to climate change, energy and journalism, which we update regularly. You can find the list
here.
For more European events, see
What’s next in Europe? – Timeline of European climate and energy policy.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
Clean Energy Wire CLEW
Dresdener Str. 15, 10999 Berlin
T: +49 30 62858 497
info@cleanenergywire.org
© Clean Energy Wire CLEW, All rights reserved.
|
|
|
|